FANDOM


Huge internet fight

OFFICIAL CLASSIC WHO POWER RANKINGS Edit

Season 1 Edit

GOD TIER:


Pretty Good Tier:


Okay Tier:


Bad Tier:


Shit Tier:


Season 2 Edit

GOD TIER:


Pretty Good Tier:


Okay Tier:


Bad Tier:


Shit Tier:


Season 3 Edit

GOD TIER:


Pretty Good Tier:


Okay Tier:


Bad Tier:


Shit Tier:

Edit

Season 4 Edit

SILVER AGE TIER:

GOD TIER:

Pretty Good Tier:

Okay Tier:

Bad Tier:

Shit Tier:

Edit

Season 5 Edit

GOD TIER:

Pretty Good Tier

Okay Tier:

Bad Tier:

Shit Tier:

  • Surprisingly, none, this season was actually pretty kind to Pat the Trout.

Season 6 Edit

GOD TIER:

Pretty Good Tier:

Okay Tier:

Bad Tier:

Shit Tier:

Season 7 Edit

GOD TIER:

Pretty Good Tier:

Okay Tier:

  • Astonishingly, none, this season was very kind to the Third Doctor. 'Course, it helps to only have four entries.

Bad Tier:

  • See above.

Shit Tier:

  • ^Ditto

Season 8 Edit

GOD TIER

Pretty Good Tier

Okay Tier

Bad Tier

  • Amazingly, none, it's not a bad season. Mostly it's just treated as such by Tennant fangirls who don't understand that not every Master can be John Simm and that the entire point of this seasons was to make the Master a regular cast member.

Shit Tier

  • See above.

Season 9 Edit

GOD TIER:

Pretty Good Tier

Okay Tier

Bad Tier

Shit Tier

Season 10 Edit

GOD TIER:

Pretty Good Tier

Okay Tier

Bad Tier

  • Well, it looks like Barry Letts has returned to form!

Shit Tier

  • Nothing for here; amazing, isn't it?

Season 11 Edit

GOD TIER:

Pretty Good Tier

Okay Tier

Bad Tier

Shit Tier

  • Barry Letts and Terrance Dicks manage to avoid shit stories, as usual.

Season 12 Edit

GOLDEN AGE TIER:

GOD TIER:

Pretty Good Tier:

Okay Tier:

Bad Tier:

  • Hinchcliffe and Holmes didn't fill this one in for this season.

Shit Tier:

  • Revenge of the Cybermen (kind of a freak accident really; the only Hinchcliffe season with the "shit tier" filled).

Edit

Season 13 Edit

GOD TIER:

Pretty Good Tier:

Okay Tier:

  • This was a pretty GOAT season.

Bad Tier:

  • Nope, nothing here

Shit Tier:

  • No filling for this one.

Season 14 Edit

GOD TIER:

Pretty Good Tier:

Okay Tier:

  • There is a reason why the Hinchcliffe/Holmes days were called the Golden Age of Doctor Who.

Bad Tier:

  • Hinchcliffe and Holmes were way too GOAT to ever fill this place.

Shit Tier:

  • Hinchcliffe's seasons were pretty based. This spot went unfilled.

Season 15 Edit

GOD TIER:

  • None now Hinchy's gone :(

Pretty Good Tier:

Okay Tier:

Bad Tier:

Shit Tier:

Season 16 Edit

GOD TIER:

Pretty Good Tier:

Okay Tier:

  • Nothing here, The Key to Time never did shit by halves.

Bad Tier:

Shit Tier:

Season 17 Edit

GOD TIER:

Pretty Good Tier:

Okay Tier:

Bad Tier:

Shit Tier:

Season 18 Edit

GOD TIER:

Pretty Good Tier:

Okay Tier:

Bad Tier:

Shit Tier:

  • None; this was one of those JNT seasons in which the script editor had a good deal of free reign, and like most JNT seasons in which the script editor had that much freedom, the God tier was filled and the shit tier wasn't.

Season 19 Edit

GOD TIER:

Pretty Good Tier:

Okay Tier:

Bad Tier:

Season 20 Edit

GOD TIER:

Pretty Good Tier:

Okay Tier:

Bad Tier:

  • Eric Saward had more free reign over this season than the previous one, and JNT was somewhat less involved. In spite of the fact that Saward could be a bit of an edgy faggot at times, it was still better to give him freedom and work largely alone than to let JNT have too much influence; hence, this tier and the shit tier never got filled.

Shit Tier:

  • See above.

Season 21 Edit

GOD TIER:

Pretty Good Tier:

Okay Tier:

Bad Tier:

  • Once again, JNT wasn't that involved, and so Saward could be his ingeniusly/idiotically edgy self and at least write and edit with relatively little restraint, thus at least giving a weird mix of daring, edgy, comfy, and so-bad-it's good. Unfortunately, it was after seeing Warriors of the Deep that Michael Grade decided to cancel this show, and JNT, already forbidden from leaving the show, realized that if he left, the show would die, and if the show died, his career would be over. So he got desparate, which resulted in the weirdness of the following season...

Shit Tier:

  • See above.

Edit

Season 22 Edit

GOD TIER:

Pretty Good Tier:

Okay Tier

  • This season? Do anything by halves? BA-HAHAHAHA!!! But seriously, this was when JNT and Eric Saward had more power over the show than the writers of the individual episodes, and yet the conflicting styles and concerns of JNT and Saward clashed a lot during this time. Hence, this season alternates between being sheer genius, and taking a massive dump on any sense of good taste, the former actually happening more often, but the latter in one instance being so bad that it almost weighs as much as the genius does on the season. This is because JNT's incredibly camp style was so bad it started to get good, and Eric Saward was, on the one hand, a lot less pretentious and a lot more daring than any of the overly safe pansies writing the show today, but on the other hand, he could be a huge edgy faggot. However, it's actually better more often than worse, and it just might be the third or fourth best JNT season. Which admittedly isn't a high standard at all.

Bad Tier:

Shit Tier:

  • Most of the stories in this season are actually considerably better than that, except for one, which is so abysmally bad that it had to have its own tier.

"Bad? No... ...It's Disastrous" Tier:

Season 23 Edit

GOD TIER:

Pretty Good Tier:

Okay Tier:

  • Like the previous season, nothing was done by halves, but unlike the prior season, there were fewer serials and considerably less freedom for Eric Saward, so only one entry each got properly filled.

Bad Tier:

  • The Ultimate Foe (would have been good if it weren't for Chicken Jane Baker writing the second episode)

Shit Tier:

Season 24 Edit

GOD TIER:

  • JNT had the maximum control for this season, so you can guess how that turned out.

Pretty Good Tier:

  • Haha, nope, not even this slot was filled during this horrible season.

Okay Tier:

Bad Tier:

  • The incredible thing is that even this slot didn't get filled. Even more incredible is comparing this season to the two seasons that followed. The difference is that this season had maximum JNT, and the following seasons had minimum JNT. Now stop blaming Saward for every single fault and failing of the prior seasons, and apologize to him for doing so.

Shit Tier:

Season 25 Edit

GOD TIER:

Pretty Good Tier:

Okay Tier:

Bad Tier

  • See how good it gets when JNT is left out of the picture?

Shit Tier:

  • Ditto^^^

Season 26 Edit

GOD TIER:

Pretty Good Tier:

The production team did it, the best season. Which its a shame that this was the end of Classic Who, as we could have had GOD tier season after another, but on the other hand Season 27 might have not lived up to these glorious pieces of televised media.

Okay Tier:

Ditto^^^

Bad Tier:

Ditto^^^

Shit Tier:

DITTO^^^

1996 Edit

Okay Tier:

OFFICIAL NUWHO POWER RANKINGS Edit

Series 1 Edit

GOD TIER:


Pretty Good Tier:


Okay Tier:


Bad Tier:


Shit Tier:


Series 2 AKA: The Worst Series Edit

GOD TIER:


Pretty Good Tier:

  • RTD doesn't fill this nearly as much as you might think. He's usually either Godly or pretty-bad-but-not-the-shittiest-thing-you-ever-seen.


Okay Tier:


Bad Tier:


Shit Tier:


Series 3 Edit

GOD TIER:


Pretty Good Tier:


Okay Tier:

  • Though this would have easily been the best Tenth Doctor series if it weren't for "miss muh Rose" (perhaps it still is in spite of this), it didn't do any shit by halves, often either being insanely good and undercredited for being so, or being utterly shitty.


Bad Tier:

Shit Tier:


Series 4 Edit

GOD TIER:


Pretty Good Tier:


Okay Tier:


Bad Tier:


Shit Tier:


Series 4 Specials Edit

GOD TIER:

  • Surprisingly, RTD didn't manage to fill this one, probably because it won't be filled if you only give RTD four stories. The Troughton Tradition is stupid, ain't it?


Pretty Good Tier:


Okay Tier:

  • Nothing was done by halves for this series.


Bad Tier:


Shit Tier:

  • The End of Time (Would have been better if it weren't for "I don't want tuggo")


Series 5 Edit

GOD TIER:


Pretty Good Tier:


Okay Tier:


Bad Tier:


Shit Tier:


Series 6 Edit

GOD TIER:


Pretty Good Tier:


Okay Tier:


Bad Tier:


Shit Tier:


Series 7 Edit

GOD TIER: Series 7 is so fucking shit mediocre.


Pretty Good Tier:


Okay Tier:


Bad Tier:


Shit Tier:


2013 Specials Edit

GOD TIER:


Okay Tier:


'Not too bad when you consider how rushed Moffat was' Tier:


Bad Tier:


Shit Tier:


Series 8 Edit

GOD TIER:


Pretty Good Tier:


Okay Tier:


Bad Tier:


Shit Tier:


Series 9 Edit

PLATINUM AGE TIER:


GOD TIER:


Pretty Good Tier:


Okay Tier:


Polarizing as Electromagnets Tier:

Shit Tier:


Series 10 Edit

GOD TIER:


Pretty Good Tier:


Okay Tier:


Bad Tier:

Shit Tier:

Note Edit

Anything else is objectively incorrect. These rankings are final, perfect and backed by hard data. Except someone put books on here, fuck that guy.

Ad blocker interference detected!


Wikia is a free-to-use site that makes money from advertising. We have a modified experience for viewers using ad blockers

Wikia is not accessible if you’ve made further modifications. Remove the custom ad blocker rule(s) and the page will load as expected.